Ever heard of the “lordship salvation” controversy? Here’s a simplified version: Some believe if you’ve prayed a prayer of salvation you are a Christian. Others believe if your life shows no sign of following Jesus Christ, you’re not a Christian.

Wherever you fall on the lordship salvation spectrum, here are two exercises* to get your students thinking about their own relationship to Jesus Christ.

First, pick three students to stand up front. The student on the left represents a person who is following Jesus Christ. (Use your own anecdotes to describe what that looks like.) The student on the right has zero interest in Jesus Christ. Doesn’t believe at all. The student in the middle prayed a prayer of salvation when he was eight. Now he’s seventeen and not walking with Jesus.

Option 1 — Break everyone into small groups for five minutes and ask each group to decide whether the guy in the middle is a Christian or not. Don’t let them just give opinions. Make them defend their positions biblically.

Option 2 — This one is more intense, so weigh it carefully before taking it on. Ask everyone to line up behind one of the three students up front. Whichever one best describes where they’re at. When everyone is lined up behind one of the three, ask them, “What if the middle row is not a true biblical category?” Then remove the middle guy and ask those lined up behind him to pick one of the other two lines.

Both of these exercises will get your group thinking about their personal faith. Just be aware that it could get messy.

* Thanks, Kevin!